I’ve just returned from SPIEL Essen, where I played the new Kingdom Come: Deliverance board game.
One of the game’s big attractions is the range of options available to players. We played for 2 hours and I really enjoyed it. It offers a rich and immersive experience. The table presence and production values were all very impressive...
But I didn’t buy it...
It's a heavy game and I know I’d never get it to the table. At that scale I cannot break away from the notion that I’d rather write and run my own TTRPG.
But there was one mechanic that really caught my attention.
The Five Finger Discount
Alongside pursuing quests, you can choose to steal from any one of the local settlements.
Each town has a guard alert level from 1-4. As players successfully steal, the guards become more alert, making further theft mechanically harder.
It’s a simple way to make a location respond to what happens within it and it got me thinking about what other ratings we could apply to a settlement in my home games.
Universal Settlement Profiles
Taking some inspiration from the Universal World Profiles in Traveller. Each settlement could have a series of characteristics rated from one to six.
The aim would be to give the GM a useful reference for describing the settlement, judging opportunities and setting difficulties.
Here are some possible characteristics with some ideas for what the ratings could represent:
Economic activity:
1 = Little trade and widespread hardship. 6 = Bustling trade and abundant opportunities.
Social disposition:
1 = Outsiders face suspicion or aggression. 6 = Hospitality and help are readily offered.
Law enforcement:
1 = Very few guards or enforcement. 6 = Numerous guards and broad patrol coverage.
Guard alertness:
1 = Guards expect little trouble. 6 = Guards actively search, question and investigate.
Civil unrest:
1 = Little open conflict or resistance. 6 = Widespread rebellion challenges civic authority.
Criminal activity:
1 = Crime is uncommon and disorganised. 6 = Criminal networks influence much of local life.
Religious influence:
1 = Little public influence. 6 = Religious authority shapes government and daily life.
To find each characteristic you could simply roll 1d6
Interpreting the results
Higher ratings doesn’t necessarily mean better, they only describe tendencies.
As such an impoverished town may still has wealthy residents. A welcoming population still has hostile individuals and heavy law enforcement doesn’t fully eliminate crime
Strange contradictions within the characteristics could be the beginning of threads of interesting encounters.
Applying the numbers to Skill Checks
The exact adjustment would depend on the game system. The rating could create advantage or disadvantage, shift a difficulty grade, or grant a bane or boon.
The ratings could determine whether finding an opportunity is easy or requires extra work. It's also very possible that the desired outcome is simply impossible within the given conditions.
The explanation within the fiction matters just as much as how the roll is modified.
Finding a buyer for expensive jewellery may depend on the economic activity of a settlement. Finding someone willing to buy the stolen jewellery may depend on the level of criminal activity. Getting the jewellery through a guarded gate would involve guard alertness, with the towns corruption level potentially offering another approach.







