Sunday, 18 October 2026

A Fiction First Simulation Game

On the back of my previous post, someone asked me:


"What are your opinions about whether there are particular systems, or types of systems, that encourage or discourage the kind of play your seeking..."


Thanks for the question; it gave me lots to chew on! 


So you need a Fiction First game? 

I think it would be fair for most people to assume that what I'm seeking is a fiction first narrative game. such PbtA, Fate, or Forged in the Dark. 

I've played plenty of fiction first games, and have had lots of fun with them, but their lack of mechanical depth often leaves me wanting...

I recently wrote a blog titled A Reflection on a Gaming Philosophy, where I outlined my thoughts on what makes a good game. I suggested that narrative systems sharpen improvisation, while traditional systems help keep the “game” in TTRPGs. That’s a broad distinction, but it captures something about what I enjoy in each.

Critical Role, the massively popular actual play show, uses D&D very successfully to create the kind of immersive, character driven experience I’m talking about. We can debate how much the system supports that experience, and how much comes from the people at the table but this clearly shows that this style of play isn’t exclusive to narrative games.


A Fiction First Simulation Game


As a GM, I want it all.

I want characters who feel real and players swept up in the drama. I want interesting choices, difficult decisions and the uncertainty of discovering what happens through play. I also want interesting mechanics to lean on, rules that help create situations and pressures that are enjoyable to engage with in their own right.

I enjoy shared storytelling, but I also want the satisfaction of playing an actual game. For me, that’s a big part of the appeal of TTRPGs.

This is why I like Mythras, a d100 simulation style system. I find it, and much of the broader BRP family, very malleable. We can lean into the more detailed procedures when those decisions feel interesting, or use a lighter touch when we want to keep things moving. In my experience, the game holds up well either way.

A lot of the enjoyment, for me, comes from the variety on offer at the table. A procedure based combat can feel exciting after several sessions of intrigue. Equally, a few sessions of free flowing roleplay can be just as rewarding as we look to establish new truths about the game world and set fresh objectives.

How much we choose to lean into the game mechanics can, and will, change from session to session.


1 comment:

  1. The beauty of d100 is that it is easy to communicate.

    You have 75% chance - roll d100!

    It is the one mechanic that gets out of the way and that you don't really have to teach.

    There are also some amazing things you can do with - from fumbles, to criticals, to power, etc... in a single dice roll.

    ReplyDelete

Three Hobbies for Life

I recently noted the next generation of social media influencers discussing the importance of having five hobbies in your life.  The list ca...